Businesses expanding internationally must understand employee misclassification policies and misclassification prevention strategies around the world to avoid legal consequences, fines, and reputational damage. To help, this guide provides a comprehensive breakdown of the risks, penalties, and solutions associated with employee vs. independent contractor classification, using the US as a specific example to understand the risks this issue poses for all global employers.
What is Employee Misclassification? A Definition of Employee Misclassification
Employee misclassification occurs when an employer incorrectly categorizes a worker as an independent contractor rather than an employee. This mistake can be unintentional due to misunderstandings of labor laws, or deliberate in order to reduce costs and responsibilities.
Unfortunately, employee misclassification may differ from country to country as different labor laws define independent contractors and how they can interact with companies differently. This variation makes it hard to know when companies are compliant on a global scale.
However, misclassification can have serious legal and financial repercussions for businesses and negatively impact workers who are denied benefits and labor protections, so it’s essential to be aware of local specifications to ensure companies and contractors are working together in a way that avoids suspicion of misclassification.
What is Employee and Worker Classification?
Employee classification determines a worker’s legal rights, tax obligations, and benefits, with employment generally entailing responsibility on the part of the hiring company. However, as the labor market shifts towards global, remote, and gig work, it’s more and more difficult to know exactly how much a company may be responsible for workers who can be hired as contractors,
Because of this, governments around the world use a variety of classification systems or factors to determine independent contractor vs employee status in order to ensure fair treatment, proper taxation, and regulatory compliance.
Misclassification thus often arises due to misunderstandings of the laws that govern different employment types, which vary from country to country. In some jurisdictions, simply calling a worker a contractor may be enough to avoid issues, while in others, even a written service contract does not exempt an employer from legal responsibilities.
Employee vs. Contractor: Key Differences
In the US, independent contractors are commonly defined using a three-prong or common law test. Essentially, this means that a working relationship is analyzed based on three characteristics: behavioral control (when, where, and how work is done), financial control (how a worker is paid and by who), and the relationship of the parties (whether the parties have agreements, contracts, and what form these take).
Since 2024, this has taken the more structured form of the Final Rule on independent contractor relationships, which breaks the responsibilities of contractor and companies into 6 factors:
- Does the opportunity for profit or loss depending on managerial skill?
- Are investments made by the worker or the potential employer?
- Is there a degree of permanence to the working relationship?
- What is the nature and degree of the potential employer’s control over the work being performed?
- To what extent is the work performed an integral part of potential employer’s business?
- Does the worker use specialized skills to perform the work?
It’s been confirmed that in the event of a dispute or investigation over status, factors 2 and 4 will carry more weight than the others, signaling once again the importance of behavioral and financial control over what determines an independent contractor in the US.
Beyond the US, a number of factors differentiate employees from independent contractors, with most countries basing their determinations on some combination of the following:
Who Decides When the Work is Performed?
Employees typically follow a set schedule determined by the employer, whereas contractors work on their own time.
Independent contractors have more control over their working hours and schedules, reflecting their greater autonomy in completing tasks.
Where is the Work Done?
Employees often work at company offices or designated locations, while independent contractors may work remotely or at their own facilities.
While the location of work is a key indicator of employment status, the rising impact of Work From Home rules has made this factor harder to determine, as a worker remotely reporting in may still be considered an employee.
Who Provides the Equipment?
Employers supply tools and resources for employees who need to perform their duties, with the employer footing the bill for equipment and expenses. Independent contractors, on the other hand, generally use their own equipment.
If a business provides essential tools, it may indicate an employer-employee relationship rather than an independent contractor arrangement unless the services provided require the contractor to work with specific internal systems or unique circumstances.
Who Performs the Work?
Employees are expected to personally complete the work assigned to them, whereas independent contractors can outsource or subcontract tasks, generally on their own initiative. The ability to delegate work is a significant distinction between the two classifications, though in many countries, companies may retain the right to place restrictions on work involving private or sensitive information through NDAs.
How Important is the Work or Services Provided?
If the worker’s role is central to business operations, they are likely an employee. Contractors usually perform non-core tasks that form part of special projects or take care of tangential needs.
A worker handling critical business functions on an ongoing basis is likely to be classified as an employee, even if labeled otherwise, though this factor is logically harder to prove due to the inherent subjectivity of what is essential.
What is the Length of the Relationship?
Employees often have long-term contracts, whether they’re fixed-term or indefinite, while independent contractors work on specific projects with typically defined end dates. A continuous, repeated, or indefinite engagement with a company increases the likelihood that a worker will be classified as an employee in a dispute.
How is the Worker Paid?
Employees receive a salary or hourly wage with tax deductions, whereas contractors are paid per project or invoice without automatic deductions. Contractors are typically responsible for their own tax filings, social security contributions, and other statutory payments.
However, while this is the case in the vast majority of countries and is often seen as the most basic determiner of contractor status, it’s not universal. In some countries, for example, companies are still required to deduct and manage social security contributions for independent contractors (or those seen as economically dependent) or are made responsible for ensuring the contractors they work with are compliant with tax and social security laws, showing the complete lack of certainty in the ways that countries define employer responsibilities.
Why Governments Care About Misclassification
- Impact on Tax Revenue – Governments rely on payroll taxes to fund essential services, but misclassification leads to tax evasion and a loss of payroll taxes, social security contributions, and other employment-related levies, thereby reducing national revenue.
- Ensuring Fair Treatment of Workers – Misclassified employees may lose out on benefits, healthcare, and labor protections, so governments aim to prevent this exploitation. Workers who are incorrectly classified as contractors may also not receive paid leave, retirement benefits, or unemployment insurance, leading to financial insecurity.
- Maintaining Business Accountability – Governments enforce strict regulations to ensure companies do not gain unfair advantages by misclassifying employees.
4 Employee Misclassification Penalties to Avoid in the US: Misclassification Under the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA)
The risks of employee misclassification vary around the world, but generally boil down to a mix of financial or criminal penalties, such as the following:
- Tax Violation Fines – Failure to properly classify workers can result in heavy fines from tax authorities. In the US, businesses that underreport employee wages or fail to withhold taxes may face substantial financial penalties of up to 25% of missing tax amounts or even criminal charges in severe cases.
- Federal Labor Law Violation Fines – In the US, businesses violating federal labor laws, including the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA), face a range of labor law violation penalties, including a $50 fine per unfiled Form W-2, 1.5% of lost wages during the period of error, 40% of unpaid FICA taxes, the full amount of the missing employer’s share of FICA taxes. These fines can quickly escalate further if employers fail to take corrective action after being notified of a violation.
- Harmed Reputation and/or Operational Capacity – Legal issues can damage a company’s reputation, deterring potential hires and clients. Companies with a history of misclassification cases may struggle to attract top talent and build customer trust, and those who repeatedly make mistakes may find their operations restricted or shut down.
- Back Wages and Benefits – Employers may be required to provide retroactive wages, benefits, and overtime pay. This can result in significant unexpected costs, particularly for businesses with a history of misclassification. Lawsuits and legal battles can then arise from misclassification claims as workers may file their own complaints with labor authorities or pursue legal action to recover wages or seek damages. Misclassified employees may be entitled to unpaid overtime, leading to costly employer liabilities. If an employer fails to recognize an employee’s entitlement to overtime pay, they may face additional penalties and wage restitution claims.
Independent Contractor vs. Employee: Which Should You Hire?
The Pros and Cons of Hiring Contractors vs. Employees
Contractors offer flexibility but lack long-term stability, while employees provide reliability but involve higher costs.
Businesses must consider their operational needs, budget constraints, and legal responsibilities when making hiring decisions.
When to Choose an Independent Contractor
Hiring contractors is ideal for short-term projects, specialized skills, and cost efficiency. Businesses looking to scale quickly without long-term commitments may benefit from using independent contractors.
How to Avoid Employee Misclassification as an Employer: Steps to Correctly Classify Workers
- Review legal definitions in relevant jurisdictions
- Assess work conditions and responsibilities
- Consult with legal experts to ensure compliance
- Use contracts that clearly define the worker’s status
- Regularly audit worker classifications
How to Correct Employee Misclassification
- Identifying and Resolving Classification Errors – Conduct internal audits and seek expert guidance to identify misclassification.
- Legal Steps to Rectify Misclassification – Employers may need to reclassify workers, pay owed wages, and adjust tax filings. Note that in this case, reclassification and admittance of past mistakes may not reduce the chances of penalties being applied but will certainly reduce the chance of future errors.
10 Common Independent Contractor-Related Misconceptions: The Myths and the Realities
Myth: Independent contractors can’t work full-time.
Reality: Contractors can work full-time but must retain control over their schedules and work methods.
Myth: A contract alone determines classification.
Reality: Classification depends on actual work conditions, not just the wording of a contract.
Myth: Independent contractors don’t have to pay taxes.
Reality: Contractors are responsible for self-employment taxes and Social Security.
Myth: Employees can become independent contractors by signing an agreement.
Reality: The law determines classification based on how work is performed, not just an agreement, with enforcement agencies often being particularly strict about workers transitioning from employees to contractors.
Myth: Independent contractors can’t be long-term workers.
Reality: Contractors can work for a company long-term if they maintain autonomy and flexibility.
Myth: Independent contractors don’t receive any benefits.
Reality: While employers aren’t required to provide benefits, some companies may offer perks to contractors.
Myth: Independent contractors can be managed like employees.
Reality: Employers cannot dictate how, when, or where contractors work without risking misclassification.
Myth: Independent contractors don’t have workplace rights.
Reality: Many labor or common laws still protect contractors, including those related to discrimination and safety.
Myth: Independent contractors can’t work for multiple clients.
Reality: True independent contractors typically serve multiple clients.
Myth: Hiring independent contractors eliminates all employer risks or costs.
Reality: Misclassifying workers as contractors entails just as much risk and can lead to penalties, fines, and legal liabilities if improperly managed.
Can You Get Misclassification Protection? Solutions for Compliance Assurance in the US and Around the World
Understanding employee misclassification policies is essential for global businesses. Proper classification prevents legal risks, ensures compliance, and protects both employers and workers.
However, navigating the complexities of international labor laws and employment relationships can be overwhelming, especially when expanding into new markets. That’s where INS Global comes in, offering expert advise and tailored solutions to help businesses hire confidently while staying compliant.
How Global Employer of Record Services Provide Legal Safeguards for Employers and Employees
An Employer of Record (EOR) is a third-party partner that helps businesses hire workers legally while ensuring compliance with classification laws. By acting as the official employer in unfamiliar situations, an EOR handles payroll, tax compliance, benefits administration, and local labor law adherence.
Hiring employees or contractors through an EOR minimizes the risk of employee misclassification by ensuring that workers are properly categorized according to jurisdiction-specific regulations. This assurance allows companies to focus on growth and productivity while leaving the complexities of HR and legal compliance to seasoned professionals.
Minimize Misclassification Risks with INS Global
INS Global offers Independent Contractor solutions that help companies stay compliant with employee misclassification policies worldwide. With nearly 20 years of experience in global workforce management, INS Global can assist businesses across over 160 countries, including all 50 states in the US.
With INS Global EOR solutions, you can ensure that the independent contractors you work with are vetted, hired, and classified correctly while benefiting from streamlined onboarding, secure payments, and localized HR support. Whether you’re expanding into new markets or optimizing your existing workforce, INS Global provides end-to-end support that safeguards your business from costly compliance issues.
Contact our expert advisors today to set up a meeting and learn more.
SHARE